And, having travelled a lot in recent years, this network really is one of the best airport Wi-Fi networks in the world. So all is well, right?
Many people, me included, have data subscriptions on their devices. This allows cellular networks to be used when no Wi-Fi is available. So I can get Skype messages, send photos, and do anything I like everywhere, or at least within my home country. There is only one place in Finland where my smartphone stops working: the Helsinki-Vantaa airport. The device sees the Wi-Fi, connects, and stops, waiting for the user to make that one click.
Of course, if I need to use the Internet I will notice all this and make that one click. However, I believe we are increasingly in an always-connected world, and information flows when it needs to. I do not want my devices to stop, I want them to keep on working. Even that one click is too much. And it is unclear what value that click brings anyone, me or the airport.
But the Helsinki-Vantaa network is one of the best. My next stop was a large hub airport in northern Europe. I checked if there was local Wi-Fi, and there was. My browser told me that I could use either the free or the paid network. I decided to try the free one first. A screen comes up that requires me to register. But the amount of information that they ask is... at least tiresome, if not privacy insensitive. The e-mail address and password I can understand. Maybe the phone number, because some airport networks send a password over on SMS. But I also had to fill in birth date and country. Why?
But this was just the start of my failed attempt to use the network. I got an error message that my chosen e-mail or password was invalid - without any explanation of why they were invalid. I guessed that perhaps I had entered an e-mail address that I had used on my previous visit, and entered another one. Not wanting to fill all information for the second time, I used the browser back button to get to the registration page. Big mistake! After changing my information and pressing register, I got an error. I should have started again from the beginning.
I could go on, but you get the point. The problems with these networks are very wide spread, and in my opinion, unnecessary. Earlier this summer I was waiting for my delayed flight at a major North American airport, and had trouble getting more than a few packets exchanged via their local network. Not enough to download any e-mails, for instance. Later a friend posted a picture of what his wireless network analyser showed at that airport: all the airport's access points were on the same three channels, making the radio environment in practice unusable.
Couple of years ago we had a large meeting in a hotel in Paris, and our network engineers ended up redesigning the hotel network to work much better, in a situation that was similar to what we saw at the above airport.
The smartphone revolution that we have seen last couple of years was initiated largely thanks to the new, easier to use touchscreen phones and operating systems. Perhaps we need a similar revolution in wireless networking. And I think we have had a lot of the technology around but now it is time to put it into use. Examples of this include Hotspot 2.0, 802.11u, EAP, and various network connectivity checkers in our devices. (I worked on EAP at the IETF over ten years ago, but it is only now that it is getting more widespread adoption. A long time!)
And this problem is not limited to Wi-Fi. Again that is just an example. I also have a lot of experience of trying to acquire SIM cards in various places. I've had great experience in some countries and with some operators. Others struggle in providing a service. Some operators sell SIM cards and the needed data allowance package in different shops. Why? And the top-up process can be difficult. An operator in Europe requires a local phone number for the process to complete. Not particularly useful for tourists, is it? An Asia-Pacific operator uses a web-page process that only works on some browsers, not all. Many countries require proof of identity before you can use a network. Perhaps I can understand that, but it does not stop there. I was once asked for a formal proof of my address within the country. How can I produce such a proof, when staying at a hotel?
Here are my guidelines for providing an effective Internet access product:
- If you want to provide an open network, make it truly open.
- If your network is for subscribers, employ an automatic authentication mechanism that does not require the user to perform a web login.
- If you charge for the use of the network, make it easy to provide the credit card information
- If you sell cellular access, make the right size SIM cards available to everyone easily. Do not force users to go through extra steps to "enable" the SIM card. You sold it, it can be enabled automatically.
- Any web-based purchase, top-up, or login process needs to be tested with all browsers and in different conditions.
- Do not collect information that you do not need.
- Radio networks need to be tested and configured properly.
In short, people want your service. Make it easy to buy and use it!
Photo credits (c) Jari Arkko and Joe Abley